C2PA's eMudhra Moment
The C2PA media provenance ecosystem lacks revocation mechanisms present in Web PKI, leaving it vulnerable to CA compromise scenarios like eMudhra. The author demonstrates forging S/MIME certificates that chain to Google’s C2PA root CA—producing a valid leaf certificate with private key ‘4’ via an undisclosed method to prove intermediate compromise is possible. Unlike TLS, C2PA’s trust model assumes intermediates will never be compromised; if they are, media verification tools cannot detect forged provenance chains. This analysis reveals that popular C2PA media verification tools offer no defense against a hypothetical CA compromise, highlighting a critical gap in an emerging ecosystem designed for media authenticity.
This post is licensed under CC BY 4.0 by the author.